Introduction: A Strategic Quarterback Move by the Saints
In a surprising turn during the 2025 NFL Draft, the New Orleans Saints selected quarterback Tyler Shough with the 40th overall pick in the second round. The move has sparked significant attention not only because of Shough’s unconventional college journey but also due to the Saints passing over the more publicized Shedeur Sanders, son of NFL legend Deion Sanders.
Let’s dive into why the Saints made this move, what Shough brings to the table, and what this means for the franchise moving forward.
Who is Tyler Shough? A Journey Across Three Colleges
Tyler Shough, 25, has had a unique and resilient path to the NFL. His collegiate career spanned seven years, featuring stops at Oregon, Texas Tech, and finally Louisville. Shough showcased adaptability, perseverance, and growth, throwing for 7,820 yards, 59 touchdowns, and 23 interceptions across 42 games.
His final year at Louisville was his best yet. He threw for 3,195 yards and 23 touchdowns, ranking 14th nationally in total offensive yards. His experience and maturity played a crucial role in his rise on draft boards leading up to the event.
Why Did the Saints Pick Tyler Shough Over Shedeur Sanders?
The Saints’ decision to pass on Shedeur Sanders—one of the draft’s most talked-about prospects—for a second consecutive round raised eyebrows. Sanders, despite his star profile and connection to Hall of Famer Deion Sanders, remains undrafted, while Shough’s name was called early in the second round.
So, why did the Saints choose Shough?
- Pro Readiness: Shough’s extended college career and complex offensive experience make him more immediately adaptable to an NFL playbook.
- Physical Tools: Standing 6’5” and 225 lbs, with a 4.63-second 40-yard dash, he has the arm strength and mobility that NFL teams crave.
- Leadership and Maturity: At 25, he brings a level of maturity that teams see as a stabilizing factor in quarterback development.
Head coach Kellen Moore, known for his offensive mind, may see Shough as the ideal candidate to develop behind veteran QB Derek Carr or potentially challenge for the starting role in the near future.
Shough’s NFL Combine and Scouting Report
Tyler Shough’s performance at the NFL Combine helped solidify his position as a serious prospect. His measurable stats and skill set impressed scouts:
- Arm Talent: Quick release and deep-ball accuracy.
- Mobility: Above-average speed for a quarterback, with good movement inside the pocket.
- Football IQ: Able to read defenses effectively and execute complex offensive schemes.
- Injury Concerns: While durable in his final year, Shough has a history of injuries that might have caused earlier hesitation from other teams.
Despite these concerns, the Saints believe his upside far outweighs the risks.
What This Means for the Saints’ QB Room
With Derek Carr under center, the Saints are not in immediate need of a starting quarterback. However, Carr turns 34 this year, and his long-term viability is a question mark. Shough’s selection marks the highest QB pick by the Saints since Archie Manning in 1971, signaling a significant investment in the team’s future under center.
Shough will likely serve as a backup in his rookie year, giving him time to learn and grow under Carr and Moore’s guidance. If developed correctly, he could become the face of the franchise within a few seasons.
NFL Community Reaction to the Pick
The pick has been met with mixed reactions from fans and analysts alike:
- Supporters applaud the Saints for choosing a seasoned, ready-to-play quarterback with a strong football IQ.
- Critics question the decision to pass on the more high-profile Sanders, especially given his upside and marketability.
However, insiders suggest the Saints were won over by Shough’s work ethic, game film, and in-person interviews during the pre-draft process.
Final Thoughts: A Calculated Gamble That Could Pay Off
The Saints’ selection of Tyler Shough at No. 40 was bold, calculated, and perhaps a glimpse into the team’s long-term vision. While many focused on Shedeur Sanders, New Orleans zeroed in on readiness, character, and system fit. Only time will tell if this gamble pays off, but if Shough continues his upward trajectory, the Saints may have quietly secured their quarterback of the future.
